Supreme Court Landmark Ruling on Unconditional Right to Delay Interest
Judgment Dated 11 November 2021The Dispute & Facts: The developer challenged statutory orders passed by the UP RERA Authority directing payment of monthly delay interest to allottees under Section 18. The promoter argued that since construction was in advanced stages and delayed due to external regulatory approvals and market fluctuations, allottees could not simultaneously retain the flat and demand interest or refund without establishing subjective fault.
Supreme Court Ruling: A 2-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court held that the right of an allottee to claim refund or monthly delay interest under Section 18 is unqualified, absolute, and unconditional. If the promoter fails to deliver possession within the contractually stipulated timeline, the allottee has an unfettered legal option under Section 18(1) proviso to either withdraw from the project with full refund plus interest, or retain the flat and demand monthly interest for every month of delay until actual handover with a valid Occupancy Certificate.