Broker or Relationship Manager Executed Trades Without Prior Consent
Outcome Odds: High (75%–90%)Your trading terminal shows intraday or derivative (F&O) transactions that you never placed, or your dealer / relationship manager (RM) placed high-volume trades without your explicit confirmation, causing severe capital drawdown or margin wipeout.
SEBI Master Circular CIR/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2017/108 mandates that stockbrokers must maintain contemporaneous recorded audio lines, SMS logs, or digital audit trails for every order instruction. Execution of verbal orders without voice recording places the entire burden of proof on the broker.
Governing Legal Provision:SEBI Stock Brokers Regulations 1992 (Schedule II Code of Conduct) & SEBI Circular CIR/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD2/CIR/P/2017/108 — Angel Broking v. SEBI (SAT Ruling) — Absence of call log shifts total financial liability onto broker.
Mandatory Tactical Action Steps:
- 1Demand Telephonic Call Logs & Voice RecordingsImmediately send an email to the broker's compliance department demanding the exact voice recording, IP log, and order placement timestamp for each disputed trade.
- 2Dispute Contract Notes within 24 HoursObject in writing to the contract notes within 24 hours of generation, stating that the orders were placed without consent and demanding immediate reversal of debit.
- 3Escalate to SMART ODR ConciliationIf the broker fails to provide verified voice logs within 7 business days, lodge an online dispute on smartodr.in requesting full reimbursement of trade losses plus brokerage.