3-Judge Bench on Mandatory Certificate & Primary vs Secondary Distinction
Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal & Ors.
Facts: In an election petition challenging nomination timing, video recordings from Returning Officer CCTV cameras were relied upon without a valid Section 65B(4) certificate because the authorities failed to furnish it despite repeated written requests.
Holding: The Supreme Court settled the conflict definitively: a certificate under Section 65B(4) (now Section 63(4) BSA) is a mandatory condition precedent to the admissibility of secondary electronic evidence. However, if the original electronic device/server itself is produced as primary evidence, no certificate is needed. Crucially, the Court clarified that the certificate need not always be filed at the very threshold—Courts can grant leave to file it before trial/marking of exhibits if the omission was inadvertent or an authority refused cooperation.
Creditor Takeaway: If your counsel inadvertently filed an old 65B affidavit in a 2025/2026 commercial suit, immediately seek leave of the Court to replace it with a BSA Section 63 Part A + Part B certificate before issues are framed or evidence is tendered.