LegalRecoveryLegalRecovery Home
BSA 2023 • SECTION 63(4)•SCHEDULE PART A + PART B•SHA-256 B2B EVIDENCE GUIDE

Replacing Old 65B Affidavits: How B2B Creditors Certify Tally/SAP Ledgers, E-Way Bills, Emails & WhatsApp Chats Under Section 63 of BSA, 2023

Executive Creditor Answer & Statutory SummaryUnder Section 63(4) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), 2023 (replacing repealed Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act), B2B creditors must certify Tally/SAP ledgers, GST E-Way Bills, emails, and WhatsApp chats using the mandatory two-part statutory Schedule: Part A signed by the AR Manager/CFO and Part B signed by an IT Custodian/Expert recording the SHA-256 hash value. Explore our Enterprise B2B Debt Recovery Hub to align digital evidence with Commercial Court, Order XXXVII, and NCLT filings.
Governing LawBSA s.63In force since 1 July 2024
Statutory FormatPart A + BParty Custody + IT Expert Hash
Hash StandardSHA-25664-char cryptographic digest
Legacy 65B RiskInadmissibleWithout Part B hash compliance
1

Why Old Section 65B Affidavits Fail in 2026 Commercial Suits

Across India’s Commercial Courts, Debt Recovery Tribunals (DRTs), and National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) benches, B2B creditors win or lose summary recovery on the strength of their digital paper trail. Every commercial claim relies on electronic outputs: a TallyPrime or SAP S/4HANA party ledger, GST portal GSTR-1/2B filings, NIC E-Way Bills, SMTP email demand notices, and WhatsApp delivery acknowledgments. Yet many corporate legal teams still annex outdated “Section 65B Indian Evidence Act” templates downloaded from legacy portals.

Following the enactment of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), 2023 (effective 1 July 2024), Section 170 formally repealed the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 for all newly instituted proceedings. Unlike the repealed Section 65B—which left litigants free to draft single-page self-serving affidavits—Section 63(4) of BSA 2023 binds every creditor to a strict statutory template in The Schedule. Any creditor managing unpaid business dues and corporate receivables who files a legacy 65B affidavit without Part B hash certification hands defense counsel an effortless technical objection to block interim attachment or leave-to-defend rulings.

The 2026 Defense Trap: Repealed Statute Citation

Defaulters routinely file preliminary objections under Order XI Rule 6 CPC and BSA s.63 arguing that ERP printouts accompanied by a repealed “s.65B IEA” affidavit lack Part B expert hash verification and cannot be read into evidence at the Order XXXVII or summary judgment stage.

The Institutional Advantage: Tamper-Proof Admissibility

When your Accounts Receivable desk pairs Part A (operational custody) with Part B (SHA-256 hash verification) at the pre-litigation notice stage via tri-channel Email, WhatsApp & Speed Post dispatch, debtors lose technical leverage and settle faster.

2

IEA Section 65B vs. BSA 2023 Section 63: Statutory Matrix

While BSA Section 63 retains the core functional-equivalence philosophy of Section 65B, Parliament introduced four decisive structural upgrades covering statutory forms, cryptographic hashing, dual signatories, and modern communication devices:

Evidentiary ParameterOld Section 65B (IEA, 1872)New Section 63 (BSA, 2023)
Governing Statute & Effective DateSection 65B, Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Repealed w.e.f. 1 July 2024 via BSA s.170).Section 63, Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), 2023 (Mandatory for all suits/petitions instituted on or after 1 July 2024).
Prescribed Statutory FormatNo statutory form prescribed in the Act; litigants drafted custom affidavits or loose declarations.Mandatory two-part statutory form in The Schedule to BSA 2023: Part A (Party/Custodian) + Part B (Expert/IT Hash Certification).
Cryptographic Hash Value RequirementSilent on cryptographic hashing; filename or printout description sufficed in routine filings.Expressly requires recording the exact Hash Value (SHA-256, SHA-1, MD5, or equivalent standard algorithm) and hash function used.
Dual-Signatory Structure (Part A + Part B)Single person in lawful control of the computer system signed the entire certificate.Part A is signed by the person in control/management (AR Manager/CFO); Part B is certified by an Expert/IT Custodian verifying the hash & device.
Scope of Devices CoveredReferred to 'computer' and 'computer output' (narrower phrasing requiring judicial extension to servers/clouds).Explicitly covers 'any communication device' and 'semiconductor memory'—directly encompassing smartphones, cloud ERPs, SaaS, and WhatsApp.
Primary Electronic Evidence ExpansionPrimary evidence limited to original physical/master storage under s.62 IEA.BSA s.57 Explanations 4–7 classify simultaneous/distributed/automated cloud copies & video recordings as Primary Evidence when duly stored.
3

4-Stage BSA Section 63 Part A + Part B Certification Workflow

To ensure Commercial Court, NCLT, or Arbitral Tribunal admissibility without evidentiary hiccups, B2B credit teams should execute this four-step chain of custody before serving final demand or filing suit:

1

Native Export

Export Tally/SAP PDFs, E-Way Bills, .eml files & WhatsApp .txt without manual Excel edits.

2

SHA-256 Hash

Generate a 64-char SHA-256 digest for each file using PowerShell Get-FileHash or sha256sum.

3

Part A Signing

AR Head / CFO signs Schedule Part A confirming ordinary course of business and lawful control.

4

Part B Expert

IT Admin / Forensic Expert signs Part B certifying the device identifiers and SHA-256 hash table.

4

Decoding Part A, Part B & Mandatory SHA-256 Hash Rules

Section 63(4) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 requires that a certificate identifying the electronic record, describing the manner of its production, and giving particulars of the device involved must be submitted in the form specified in The Schedule. That Schedule is divided into two distinct legal declarations:

Schedule • Part A

To Be Filled by the Party (AR Manager / CFO)

  • • Name, designation, and identity of the authorized party producing the record.
  • • Description of the electronic record (e.g., Tally Ledger, Form EWB-01, WhatsApp chat).
  • • Statement that the computer/communication device was regularly used to store or process information during ordinary business activities.
  • • Confirmation that the device operated properly during the material period, or that any brief malfunction did not affect record accuracy.
  • • Device details: Make, Model, Serial Number / IMEI / Server Instance ID.
Schedule • Part B

To Be Filled by the Expert / IT Custodian

  • • Name, qualification, and role of the IT Administrator, System Custodian, or Section 79A IT Act Expert.
  • • Confirmation of the exact Hash Value (e.g., 64-character SHA-256 hex string) for each electronic file.
  • • Specification of the Hash Function applied (SHA-256 is strongly preferred over legacy MD5/SHA-1).
  • • Verification that the digital output matches the source file stored on the enterprise server or mobile device without alteration.
  • • Date, place, and signature of the technical certifier alongside Part A.

Practical Command: Generating a Verifiable SHA-256 Hash in 3 Seconds

Your IT Administrator or Finance Controller does not need expensive forensic software to compute a court-verifiable SHA-256 hash. Built-in OS utilities generate the exact 64-character digest:

# Windows PowerShell:
Get-FileHash -Path "C:\Evidence\Debtor_Tally_Ledger.pdf" -Algorithm SHA256

# macOS / Linux Terminal:
sha256sum Debtor_Tally_Ledger.pdf
B2B Electronic Evidence Playbooks

4 Commercial Evidence Scenarios & BSA s.63 Certification SOPs

Select an institutional evidence source below to inspect the defense objection risk, statutory basis, Part A + Part B workflow, and ready-to-adapt clause.

Accounting Ledger AdmissibilityBSA 2023 s.63(4) & Schedule (Part A by AR Head/CFO + Part B by IT Admin/System Custodian); BSA s.28 (Books of account regularly kept in business).

B2B Creditor Situation

Your Accounts Receivable team exports a 3-year party ledger, ageing statement, and tax invoice PDFs from TallyPrime, SAP S/4HANA, or Zoho Books for an Order XXXVII summary suit or IBC Section 9 petition.

Defense Objection Risk

Defense counsel objects that an uncertified ERP printout is inadmissible secondary electronic evidence, or challenges an old 'Section 65B IEA' affidavit that lacks Part B IT-custodian hash verification.

Step-by-Step BSA Section 63 Compliance SOP

  1. 1Export the party ledger and individual tax invoices in non-editable PDF/A format directly from TallyPrime, SAP, or Zoho Books without manual Excel edits.
  2. 2Compute the exact SHA-256 cryptographic hash string for each exported PDF file using a verifiable hashing utility (PowerShell Get-FileHash or sha256sum).
  3. 3Execute Part A of the BSA s.63 Schedule through the Accounts Receivable Manager / Authorized Signatory describing the ERP server, backup routine, and normal business use.
  4. 4Execute Part B of the BSA s.63 Schedule through the IT Administrator or ERP System Custodian recording the exact SHA-256 hash values and server/terminal device identifiers.
Sample BSA Section 63 Schedule Clause

“Part A & Part B Declaration: The attached TallyPrime / SAP Ledger Extract (File: Debtor_Ledger_FY24-26.pdf, SHA-256: [64-char hex]) was generated in the ordinary course of accounting from a regularly maintained enterprise server operating without malfunction.”

6

Supreme Court Precedents Governing Electronic Certificates

Because BSA Section 63 re-enacts the foundational admissibility condition of Section 65B(4) while adding the statutory Schedule, Supreme Court jurisprudence from Anvar P.V. and Arjun Panditrao Khotkar continues to govern commercial litigation strategy:

(2020) 7 SCC 1, Supreme Court of India (3-Judge Bench)Judgment Dated 14 July 2020

3-Judge Bench on Mandatory Certificate & Primary vs Secondary Distinction

Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal & Ors.

Facts: In an election petition challenging nomination timing, video recordings from Returning Officer CCTV cameras were relied upon without a valid Section 65B(4) certificate because the authorities failed to furnish it despite repeated written requests.

Holding: The Supreme Court settled the conflict definitively: a certificate under Section 65B(4) (now Section 63(4) BSA) is a mandatory condition precedent to the admissibility of secondary electronic evidence. However, if the original electronic device/server itself is produced as primary evidence, no certificate is needed. Crucially, the Court clarified that the certificate need not always be filed at the very threshold—Courts can grant leave to file it before trial/marking of exhibits if the omission was inadvertent or an authority refused cooperation.

Condition Precedent for Secondary Copies — Curable Before Exhibit Marking

Creditor Takeaway: If your counsel inadvertently filed an old 65B affidavit in a 2025/2026 commercial suit, immediately seek leave of the Court to replace it with a BSA Section 63 Part A + Part B certificate before issues are framed or evidence is tendered.

(2014) 10 SCC 473, Supreme Court of India (3-Judge Bench)Judgment Dated 18 September 2014

Foundational Rule: Electronic Evidence Governed Exclusively by Special Provision

Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer & Ors.

Facts: CDs containing recorded speeches were produced in court without an accompanying electronic evidence certificate, and the party attempted to prove them through oral testimony under general secondary evidence rules (Sections 63 and 65 IEA).

Holding: Overruling State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, the Supreme Court held that electronic records are governed by a complete code in Section 65B (now Sections 62 and 63 of BSA 2023). Oral evidence cannot substitute for the statutory certificate when proving a printout, PDF, or copied electronic extract.

Oral Testimony Cannot Cure Missing Electronic Certificate

Creditor Takeaway: An Accounts Receivable Manager stepping into the witness box cannot orally 'verify' a Tally ledger printout or WhatsApp screenshot. Without a compliant BSA s.63 certificate, the document is legally inadmissible.

(2018) 2 SCC 801 -> Overruled in (2020) 7 SCC 1Clarified 14 July 2020

Overruling of 'Party Not in Possession' Relaxation & Device Control Duty

Shafhi Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh (Overruled by Arjun Panditrao)

Facts: A two-judge bench in Shafhi Mohammad had suggested that a party who is not in possession of the electronic device from which a document was produced could be exempted from filing a certificate.

Holding: The three-judge bench in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar expressly overruled Shafhi Mohammad, holding that the statutory mandate cannot be diluted merely on grounds of inconvenience. A party needing third-party electronic data (such as telecom CDRs, bank server logs, or GSTN backend logs) must apply to the Court/Tribunal to summon the third-party custodian under the relevant procedural code.

No Blanket Exemption for Third-Party Cloud / Portal Records

Creditor Takeaway: For GSTN, NIC E-Way Bill, and MCA portal records downloaded on your company's terminal, your AR Head & IT Admin certify the download device and SHA-256 hash—never assume 'public portal' status exempts BSA s.63.

7

Debtor Defense Objections & BSA s.63 Pre-Emption Matrix

Use this pre-filing matrix to neutralize the six most common evidentiary objections raised by corporate debtors in Order XXXVII summary suits, Commercial Courts, and NCLT Section 9 hearings:

Defense ObjectionStatutory HookCreditor Pre-Emption Protocol
Outdated 'Section 65B IEA' Title on CertificateBSA 2023 s.63 & s.170Use the exact statutory heading 'Certificate under Section 63(4) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (Read with The Schedule — Part A & Part B)' for all proceedings instituted on or after 1 July 2024.
Missing SHA-256 / Hash Value in Part BBSA 2023 Schedule (Part B)Generate a 64-character SHA-256 digest for every PDF ledger, E-Way Bill, .eml email, and .zip WhatsApp export before filing. List filename, byte size, hash algorithm, and exact hex string in an annexure table.
Single Signatory Claiming Both Operational & IT ControlBSA 2023 Schedule (Part A & B)Split execution cleanly: AR Manager / CFO signs Part A (business custody & lawful control) and IT Admin / External Forensic Expert signs Part B (device integrity & hash verification). In SMEs without separate IT staff, explicitly record dual role & technical competence in Part B.
Cropped WhatsApp Screenshots Without Phone/IMEI DataBSA 2023 s.63(2) & (4)Export the full WhatsApp chat (.txt/.zip) alongside full-screen captures showing the debtor's mobile number, date/time, and blue ticks. Record handset model, OS version, SIM number, and IMEI in Part A.
Edited Excel / CSV Ledger Extracts Instead of Native ERP PDFsBSA 2023 s.28 & s.63Export locked PDF/A statements directly from TallyPrime, SAP, or Zoho Books. Never run manual formulas or re-type rows in Excel before hashing, as defense counsel will allege post-export manipulation.
Unverified Email Forward Printouts (Missing SMTP Headers)BSA 2023 s.63 & IT Act s.13Preserve raw .eml or .msg files containing SMTP Message-ID, SPF/DKIM pass headers, and recipient timestamps. Hash the .eml file itself rather than only a printed PDF of the email body.
8

10-Point BSA Section 63 Pre-Filing Audit Checklist

Before your litigation counsel files a plaint, summary suit, or insolvency petition, verify all ten compliance checkpoints across your Accounts Receivable and IT teams:

✓1. Verify Filing Date Under BSA s.170

Confirm whether the suit, NCLT petition, or arbitration commenced on or after 1 July 2024. All post-transition filings require BSA s.63.

✓2. Lock Native ERP Exports (No Excel Edits)

Export party ledgers and tax invoices directly from TallyPrime, SAP, or Zoho Books as PDFs without manual post-export editing.

✓3. Preserve Raw .eml & WhatsApp .txt Exports

Archive raw .eml/.msg email notice files (with SMTP headers) and full WhatsApp chat exports alongside full-frame screenshots.

✓4. Download Official GSTN & E-Way PDFs

Pull GSTR-1, GSTR-2B/3B summaries, and Form EWB-01 E-Way Bills directly from government portals with download timestamps.

✓5. Compute SHA-256 Hash for Every File

Run PowerShell Get-FileHash or sha256sum on each exhibit file to generate a tamper-evident 64-character hexadecimal digest.

✓6. Draft Schedule Part A (AR / CFO Signatory)

Detail normal business operation, device custody, lawful control, and absence of malfunction in Part A of the statutory Schedule.

✓7. Draft Schedule Part B (IT / Expert Signatory)

Record the exact device identifiers, hash algorithm (SHA-256), and complete hash table in Part B signed by the IT custodian or expert.

✓8. Include Device IMEI & Server Identifiers

Document smartphone IMEI/model for WhatsApp evidence and server hostname/ERP instance ID for Tally/SAP ledgers.

✓9. Pair with Order XI Rule 6 CPC Declaration

In Commercial Courts, align BSA s.63 Part A/B particulars with the mandatory Order XI Rule 6 electronic records disclosure list.

✓10. Store Master Hash Archive Read-Only

Retain an unaltered read-only copy of all hashed files so the original digital exhibit matches the Part B digest during trial.

Track 1 • Single B2B Notice + BSA s.63 Audit

Test 1 Live Overdue Case Now (&rupee;999)

Advocate-drafted commercial demand notice backed by Tally/SAP ledger verification, E-Way Bill & WhatsApp evidence indexing, and tri-channel dispatch (Email + WhatsApp + Speed Post RPAD) logged for BSA 2023 s.63 admissibility.

Open Self-Serve Portal →
Track 2 • Enterprise AR & Institutional Batch Desk

Have 10 to 10,000+ Defaulters? Upload CSV / Activate Institutional Desk

Automate multi-channel legal notice dispatch across thousands of overdue ERP invoices with standardized SHA-256 dispatch logs, Speed Post RPAD tracking, and BSA 2023 s.63 Part-A & Part-B readiness for Commercial Courts and NCLT.

9

Frequently Asked Questions: BSA Section 63 Certificates

Did Section 63 of BSA 2023 completely replace Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act?
Yes. With the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), 2023 coming into force on 1 July 2024, the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 was repealed under Section 170 of the BSA. Section 63 of the BSA replaces Section 65B for all suits, NCLT insolvency petitions, criminal complaints (such as NI Act s.138), and arbitrations instituted on or after 1 July 2024.
What is the difference between Part A and Part B of the BSA Section 63 Schedule?
Unlike old Section 65B which had no statutory template, BSA 2023 appends a mandatory Schedule split into two parts. Part A is executed by the party/officer in lawful control of the device or ERP system (such as the Accounts Receivable Head or CFO) confirming regular business operation and output accuracy. Part B is executed by an Expert or IT Custodian certifying the cryptographic Hash Value (such as SHA-256 or MD5) and device/server integrity.
Is a SHA-256 hash value mandatory in a BSA Section 63 certificate?
Yes. Part B of The Schedule under Section 63(4) of BSA 2023 expressly contains fields for the 'Hash value' and the 'Hash function' (algorithm) used, such as SHA-256, SHA-1, or MD5. Filing a certificate in a commercial suit without documenting the cryptographic hash value invites immediate defense objections that the statutory Schedule was not complied with.
Who should sign Part B if an MSME or mid-sized B2B company has no in-house IT department?
In large enterprises, the internal IT Administrator, CISO, or an external Section 79A IT Act Examiner / digital forensics expert signs Part B. For MSMEs or proprietorships without a dedicated IT team, either an external IT consultant/CA who manages the Tally server or a technically competent officer who extracted the file and verified the SHA-256 hash can sign Part B, explicitly stating their technical role and hash verification method.
How do I prove WhatsApp blue-tick legal notices and chats under BSA Section 63?
Export the complete WhatsApp chat thread (.txt/.zip) using the 'Export Chat' feature and capture uncropped screenshots showing the debtor's registered mobile number, timestamp, and double blue ticks. Compute the SHA-256 hash of both the exported chat file and screenshots, record the smartphone make, model, SIM number, and IMEI in Part A, and certify the hash in Part B.
Can we cure an old 'Section 65B IEA' affidavit already filed in a 2025 or 2026 commercial suit?
Yes, in most cases. Relying on the Supreme Court's 3-Judge Bench ruling in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal (2020) 7 SCC 1, an electronic evidence certificate is a curable procedural requirement prior to the marking of exhibits at trial. Your counsel can file an application seeking leave to place a fresh, compliant BSA Section 63 Part A + Part B certificate on record.
Do TallyPrime, SAP, and Zoho Books ledgers still need a BSA Section 63 certificate?
Yes, whenever you file PDF exports or paper printouts of your TallyPrime, SAP, or Zoho Books party ledger in court or NCLT, those printouts are secondary electronic records requiring a BSA Section 63(4) Part A + Part B certificate—unless the native server/database itself is produced for direct inspection as primary evidence under Section 57.
10

Primary Statutory Citations & Supreme Court Authorities

All statutory commentary, Part A & Part B Schedule workflows, and defense pre-emption protocols in this guide are derived from primary Indian legislation and binding Supreme Court precedent:

Authored & Vetted by: Anuj Anand Malik, Advocate & Founder, AMA Legal SolutionsLast Verified: November 2026 • CORE-26 Enterprise B2B Recovery
Contextual Legal Library

Related Cheque Bounce, Banking Auto-Debit & Cyber Fraud Guides

View All Legal Notice Categories →